Sify News
Web Sify
Follow us on
Give a topic: Filmfare Awards
Sify Home >> Movies >> Messageboard
Message Board
Where did Kadal go wrong?

Mani Ratnam's latest film Kadal never really warmed up to the box office. He had A R Rahman and exceptional cinematography. Yet, everything from his script to the debutants were met with mixed reviews. Some loved it. Most were disappointed. Now, the distributors are asking for their money back.

Where exactly did Mani Ratnam go wrong? Let us know.


Maximum characters allowed - 1000
Fields marked with * are Mandatory
Latest Messages Total messages : 6 | Today’s messages : 0
Posted By: Anand Bala On:18/02/2013
Screenplay not light and engaging
comedy untouched
Arjun villan role was comedy
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Ramkumar On:15/02/2013
The movie did start brilliantly .nd i think mani got confused on how to go with the second half which was boring and had the audience boo. The second half should have been more gripping and tighter. dont know whether mani was in unchartered territory.we have all grown watching mani movies nayakan mounaragam anjali roja kannathil dilse guru etc. mani should come back to his core of urban movies portraying relationship/love .
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: sivaraj On:14/02/2013
film is a average movie compared to mani ratnam standards;and very wrong time to release in midst of viswaroopam; everyone was shell shocked seeing the harassment handed over by tn govt. to senior veteran kamal and wanted to see only viswaroopam; literally very very wrong time of release
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Dubakoor On:14/02/2013
Simple - it is time to Manirathnam to retire - thats it - Each director/actor have a life cycle because generation changes and change is constant - If a director keeps on harping his same pattern - Probability of film failing is high - that is what had happened to Kadal
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Hema On:13/02/2013
According to me, a movie should have many sub characters. The story revolves around only 4 main characters. Even the displays repeatedly showing these 4 main characters only. People got bored by seeing this in the ads. Also, in this modern world, real surroundings should be given more priority rather than the scenery locations.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: rejath On:13/02/2013
Kadal is a beautiful film... its not the first time a Mani Ratnam is falling at the boxoffice... Dil se, Iruvar, Yuva, Kannathil Muthamittal were flops... all these films were great & people realized the greatness much later... Kadal will be discussed in years to come..
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward

Latest News
Was Tori Spelling's Ebola scare cover-up
Backstreet Boys win legal battle, get ho
Anil Kapoor ropes in a new director for
Thulasi celebrates her 17th birthday
'Mentor' Usher 'not happy' with 'protege
Katie Price puts silicone implants on sa
Most-viewed on Sify Movies
Lara & Mahesh's Goan wedding
Fashion Police targets Kollywood
The hottest lips in Bollywood!
Celebrating sexy siren Namitha
Britney Spears' hottest videos!
Top Videos
Reactions flow after Jethmalani questions govt's inability to reveal names of black money holders 
Shashi Tharoor participates in cleanliness drive 
Politicos react after Pak again violates ceasefire along LoC  
George-Amal To Celebrate Third Wedding Celebration in England 
Devotees take holy dip in Yamuna on Bhai Dooj