Sify News
Web Sify
Follow us on
Give a topic: Filmfare Awards
Sify Home >> Movies >> Messageboard
Message Board
Topic
Is Suraj to blame for Jiah Khan suicide?

The police has arrested Suraj Pancholi. Jiah Khan's mother is tweeting about his 'guilt'. And now, every lurid detail of his relationship with Jiah is public knowledge.

But we should ask ourselves: is Suraj really to be blamed for Jiah Khan's suicide?

After all, he didn't hand Jiah the dupatta she hanged herself with. She made that desperate choice all by herself - one most of us would never make.

So tell us, is there any one we can truly blame?


More
>>

 
 *
 *
 *
Maximum characters allowed - 1000
 
 
  
 
Fields marked with * are Mandatory
 
   
 
Latest Messages Total messages : 26 | Today’s messages : 0
Posted By: shrikant On:14/06/2013
In this case it seems lot of things happened between Jiah & Suraj that too for 1 year. This is definitely a case of instigation to commit suicide.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Arshin On:14/06/2013
No
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Sangita Koyal On:14/06/2013
One cannot absolve a man completely of having not read the emotional state of his girl friend, but nevertheless a woman should not get so weak that her source of happiness or sorrow depends on one man or any one human being. A person must be in charge of one's life at all times. We come alone, we go alone, why should our life be joined to another to such an extent. Also a family should sensitise themselves to a person who is emotionally weak and has been capable of suicide attempts. What stopped her mother to get her psychological help the last time she attempted to kill herself! One cannot blame the guy of such a severe crime that he did not control in any manner. Well guys or girls need to be aware of signals that warn you of somebody whom you are involved with being imbalance or obsessive and steer clear of such relations with some responsible family member/s being aware of the same.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Sangita Koyal On:14/06/2013
One cannot absolve a man completely of having not read the emotional state of his girl friend, but nevertheless a woman should not get so weak that her source of happiness or sorrow depends on one man or any one human being. A person must be in charge of one's life at all times. We come alone, we go alone, why should our life be joined to another to such an extent. Also a family should sensitise themselves to a person who is emotionally weak and has been capable of suicide attempts. What stopped her mother to get her psychological help the last time she attempted to kill herself! One cannot blame the guy of such a severe crime that he did not control in any manner. Well guys or girls need to be aware of signals that warn you of somebody whom you are involved with being imbalance or obsessive and steer clear of such relations with some responsible family member/s being aware of the same.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Anand On:14/06/2013
Not at all.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: kunju On:14/06/2013
Suraj should not be held responsible for Jiah's death. She was unable to handle her life and hence committed suicide. Lots of cases can be cited for love turning sour, did everyone involved commit suicide. Jiah was mentally weak.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: V Madan On:14/06/2013
Yes he should be held responsible for it. Emotions make one's life and emotions kill a man. this is what Jiah did. Everyone needs true relationship but few like this boy make mockery of true love.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Karan On:13/06/2013
He Should not be Blamed for Her Stupid Suicide, Its very Worng to accuse Him ,only reason being in relationship, having an abortion etc.This would be 1 of many reasons adding to Her Struggling Bollywood career doesnt make him abetting her suicide!!
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Ramesh Sethi On:12/06/2013
No way should Suraj be responsible. She was stupid to go along with the so called love story angle
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: chetan salian On:12/06/2013
If the 5 letters found in suraj's possession contain evidence that jiah was raped, abused by him and forced to undergo an abortion then suraj should be punished......
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
1  2  3 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest News
Cate Blanchett admits to being intimidat
STR to dance with four generation heroin
Sonam Kapoor: Bollywood's 'hungry young
Anuj Sachdeva shares light moments with
Cate Blanchett 'f***ing' proud of U.N. G
Robin Williams' 639-acre Napa estate up
More  
 
Most-viewed on Sify Movies
Lara & Mahesh's Goan wedding
Fashion Police targets Kollywood
The hottest lips in Bollywood!
Celebrating sexy siren Namitha
Britney Spears' hottest videos!
More 
Top Videos
Three militants, three civilians killed in encounter in Arnia sector of JandK  
Politicos react as Black Money debate likely to resume in Parliament 
Kanye West to swap music career for more lucrative 'fashion' 
IPL Spot fixing case: Hearing in Supreme Court adjourned till Dec 1 
Naseeruddin Shah launches his book 'And Then One Day- A Memoir'  
More