Sify News
Web Sify
Follow us on
Give a topic: Filmfare Awards
Sify Home >> Movies >> Messageboard
Message Board
Is Suraj to blame for Jiah Khan suicide?

The police has arrested Suraj Pancholi. Jiah Khan's mother is tweeting about his 'guilt'. And now, every lurid detail of his relationship with Jiah is public knowledge.

But we should ask ourselves: is Suraj really to be blamed for Jiah Khan's suicide?

After all, he didn't hand Jiah the dupatta she hanged herself with. She made that desperate choice all by herself - one most of us would never make.

So tell us, is there any one we can truly blame?


Maximum characters allowed - 1000
Fields marked with * are Mandatory
Latest Messages Total messages : 26 | Today’s messages : 0
Posted By: Mihir Ramkrishna On:12/06/2013
No Suraj should not be blamed. In the present day set up when we are talking about women being self reliant and independent come what may Jiah Khan should not have taken this drastic step. This goes on to prove that Jiah was not Strong mentally and hence she buckled easily to take such a step. Jiah should have taken on the adversities and not have this escapist mentality
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: surinder On:12/06/2013
Suraj Pancholi, is totally responsible for the suicide of Jiah Khan, As because as per her letter he falsely promised her that he will marry her and after having physical relation with her for a long time and which resulted to her pregnant and she had to abort the baby with great pain. So he should be held responsible for her death and thus he should be harshly punished so that other man should not do such thing to any girl.

Court should punish him for his act of cruelty to her, thus to teach a lesson to such types of boys.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Neeta Shetty On:12/06/2013
Suraj Pancholi is definitely to be blamed in this case, as he was physically abusive with her and treated her badly. Her suicide letter mentions how Suraj used to ignore her . surely there may have been many more such instances for her to take such a drastic step. Suicide rarely take places because of a one off incident.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: VA On:12/06/2013
He should be punished [May be not up to murder]as he is the main reason.Enjoy with a Girl only with responsibility as they have to carry a child etc. Men as free birds should not be 100% free.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Harish L On:12/06/2013
It may not be right on anybody's part to blame only one side. All has obviously happened in confluence as such blaming one would be inappropriate. People should be made to learn more about Morality and Humanity in the present social condition which is the result of westranisation. One should be taught to pick and choose the good values in life.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
Posted By: Nitin On:12/06/2013
No certainly not. Suraj shouldn't be the only one responsible. Rabiya Khan too is equally party to it. As a mother what was had been happy for the relationship till date. (Despite all the details which are coming out now) She was totally aware of this and kept quite till now. Point regarding "rape" I guess this is highly subjective. Its Jiah version that its a rape. She olone knew what it was in actual.
Accusing someone by sucide note is not a right appraoch. If this was the case our dear prime minisiter " Mr Manmohan SIngh" would be in jail for very long time. e.g. Imagine the plight of farmers in Mahastra every day close 10 people perform suicide as they are burdoned by the economic crisis. In macro sense who is responsible for this mess ? It our prime minister for the economic and agricultre policies.

I prey that some basic sense shoudl prevail before calling someone as responsible.
Post Reply | Report abuse | Forward
1  2  3 

Latest News
'PK' surpasses Rs.25 crore mark on openi
Bohemia leaves fans spellbound with hard
Kourtney K admits didn't like beau Scott
Subhash Ghai, Delhi BJP chief inaugurate
Ali Fazal to pen short film
Big B meets PM Modi in capital
Most-viewed on Sify Movies
Lara & Mahesh's Goan wedding
Fashion Police targets Kollywood
The hottest lips in Bollywood!
Celebrating sexy siren Namitha
Britney Spears' hottest videos!
Top Videos
South Asia Newsline 20 December, 2014 
Mohan Bhagwat's 'bhule-bhatke' remark draws flak, BJP-RSS support him 
J and K Assembly Polls: State witnesses highest turnout in the last 25 years; overall voting turnout 65% 
Jharkhand polls' final phase witnesses 71.25% voter turnout  
Burdwan blast accused Shanhnoor Alam sent to 14 days judicial custody