The Little All-America team honors players from Division II, III and NAIA.
Zulli tied a Division II record with 54 touchdowns passes, set a record for TDs responsible for with 56 and threw for 4,747 yards.
Quiteh, who was an Little All-American in 2010 as a freshman, went over 2,000 yards rushing for the second time in his career. He leads Division II in rushing at 176.8 yards per game and has scored 24 touchdowns.
Michael Hill of St. Joseph, Mo., another Hill Trophy finalist, and the second-leading rusher in D-II behind Quiteh, was selected to the first-team. Hill averages 154.9 yards rushing.
Mount St. Joseph running back James Clay, who leads Division III with 212 yards per game, also was a first-team selection.