Even though they drew blank in both England and Australia, they lost only two matches by an innings margin.
Dhoni's men have already suffered four innings defeat in the last five Tests. Trailing by 386 runs in the Headingley Test, India replied with 510 in the second innings. Unlike Dhoni, Pataudi responded to the occasion with a sterling knock of 148.
There is another reason why the men of '67 could look down on Dhoni's team. While only Rahul Dravid has been a centurion in the past two series abroad, Pataudi and M L Jaisimha (101 at Brisbane) ensured they had more than one century-maker in their ranks.
Presently, Dhoni's men are a shade better than the team of '59, but only by a wafer-thin margin.
It could all change in Adelaide. During the season of 1958-59, India lost 3-0 to West Indies at home and 5-0 away to England. It would make it eight losses out of 10 Tests in that dreadful spell of nine months.
But those men in whites could still salvage two draws. Dhoni and his team have drawn blank in England and Australia so far.
Ex-players call for India skipper Dhoni's headAnother perspective could truly reflect how dismal Dhoni's men have been. When India lost eight Tests from two series in 1958-59, it had no less than four captains in the space of four Tests.
When West Indies arrived in the winter of 1958, India began with Polly Umrigar and then handed over the leadership to Ghulam Ahmed for two Tests. For the final two Tests, Vinoo Mankad and Hemu Adhikari led the team into the middle.
Dhoni, on the contrary, is at the helm presently and completely secure as leader.
In those two wretched series of 50s and 60s, the teams were a cut above what England and Australia have been able to throw at the Indians in the last seven months.
The likes of Wes Hall, Fred Trueman and Brian Statham in 1958-59 and John Snow and Graham McKenzie in 1967-68 were the legends of the game.
James Anderson, Stuart Broad and Tim Bresnan for England and James Pattinson, Peter Siddle and Ben Hilfenhaus for Australia, with all due respects, still have some way to go.
Thus the final Test at Adelaide could be more important in more ways than one.