Review: Chittagong re-creates history with flair
By: Subhash K Jha
Critic's Rating: 17/5
Thursday 11 October 2012
Manoj Bajpayee, Nawazuddin Siddiqui, Rajumar Yadav, Jaideep Ahlawat
Chittagong is the real thing. Bravely bonafide and not afraid to show a humane side to the Britishers without taking away from the heroism of the freedom fighters, the film packs a great deal of cinematic moments in less than two hours of playing time.
Its beauty is more by decree than design, less self-conscious than generally seen in films that project periodicity.
We see the verdant hamlet in Bangladesh, beautifully captured by cinematographer Eric Zimmerman, as a mysterious sinister area of insurgent activity. Debutant director Bedabrata Pain lets the weight of his rigorous research sit comfortably on the narrative.
The patriotic fervour is never allowed to weigh down the characters. Every member of Masterda's (Manoj Bajpayee) rebellious gang comes across as a sharply etched character whose patriotic pride couldn't hide the all-too-human side.
There is a tender romance tucked away in the narrative between Nirmal Sen (Nawazuddin Siddiqui) and the comely plucky girl who eggs him on from the sidelines. Their courtship doesn't come to a happy ending. But at least they tried.
The film is done with a smiling nod to the spirit of romance during times of ferocious "deshbhakti". It's almost like a tribute to the war-and-love themes of Gabriel Garcia Marquez.
Sadly Chittagong never allows itself to get passionate about patriotism or love. For better or worse, Pain keeps the emotions firmly reined-in. Except for some portions of manipulative background music, the narrative eschews over-statement, and opts for a gently persuasive approach that serves the film's valorous theme in good stead.
Shankar Mahadevan's expressive voice sings out Prasoon Joshi's sturdy poetry with robust impact.
There is a poetic element running through the film, as though the world that Pain creates so diligently would topple over if the freedom fighters didn't seek another kind of freedom before duty beckons.
The entire uprising in 1930 is seen through the eyes of a boy-soldier Jumku, played with wonderful understanding, innocence and wisdom by Delzad Hilwale. The boy is a valuable discovery, on a par with the best juvenile performers we've seen recently. Manoj in the central role of Masterda is surprisingly restrained. There are many episodes where the actor would have fornicated with a flag-waving flamboyance. In keeping with the film's mellow mood, Manoj chooses understatement.
Nawazuddin and Raj Kumar Yadav are as usual so in-character that one has to remind oneself that these are the same actors who not so long ago played anti-social elements in Gangs Of Wasseypur.
Long live the upsurge of acting talent that has taken over Bollywood. Now if only the Rs.100-crore club could accommodate talent alongside star power.
The relationship that develops between Jumku and the British officer (Barry John, perfectly pitched to portray the dilemma of a Britisher caught between duty and emotion) reminded me of Paan Singh Tomar and his senior officer in the army. Sometimes two unlikely souls divided in their loyalties cross the border to mingle with the adversary.
Chittagong doesn't portray the Britishers as only ogres and sadists. Thank goodness for some restraint in the conflict. For cinema to accommodate history, there must be a sense of balance between drama and authenticity. Chittagong manages that balance quite well.
One misses the sharp high points of drama that constitute the historical epics in Hollywood by, say, David Lean. Bedabrata Pain, I suspect, doesn't strive to create history, he recreates it.
Rating: 4 stars